Consumer Reports 2025: Top 5 Makeup Brush Brands with Minimal Bristle Shedding – Test Results & Guide

Bristle shedding is a persistent headache for makeup users, disrupting application precision, wasting product, and shortening brush lifespan. In its 2025 annual analysis, Consumer Reports (CR) put over 60 brush brands through rigorous testing to pinpoint those with minimal shedding, evaluating durability, bristle quality, and real-world usability. Here are the top 5 brands that excelled, backed by CR’s data-driven findings.

1. Sigma Beauty: The Professional’s Choice

A staple in pro makeup kits, Sigma Beauty claimed CR’s top spot with a near-flawless shedding score. In CR’s 200-cycle wear test—simulating 6 months of weekly use—the brand’s Best of Beauty Award-winning brushes shed only 1 bristle. Key to its performance: Sigmax HD synthetic fibers, engineered for strength and softness, paired with triple-bonded ferrules (metal sleeves) using CR-rated “superior” anti-shed glue. “Their bristle lock technology prevents loosening even with heavy cream products,” noted CR’s lead tester. Priced at $25–$58, Sigma targets serious enthusiasts and professionals seeking long-term reliability.

2. Real Techniques: Best Value for Daily Use

For budget-conscious users, Real Techniques stood out as CR’s “Best Value” pick. In 50 simulated daily uses, its brushes shed just 3 bristles—impressive for a brand averaging $8–$18 per brush. The secret? Cruelty-free synthetic bristles treated with a proprietary coating to reduce fraying, plus aluminum ferrules with reinforced crimping to secure bristle roots. Co-founded by makeup artist sisters Sam and Nic Chapman, the brand balances affordability with durability, making it ideal for everyday makeup lovers.

3. Fenty Beauty: Style Meets Durability

Rihanna’s Fenty Beauty proved it’s more than a trend—CR’s tests gave it a 4.8/5 for minimal shedding. In 100 uses (mimicking monthly heavy use), only 2 bristles fell out. Its FlexiBristle™ synthetic fibers are heat-resistant and pre-trimmed to prevent split ends, while ergonomic handles reduce hand fatigue. “Younger users praised its sleek design, but it’s the bristle retention that won us over,” CR reported. Priced at $15–$32, it appeals to fashion-forward shoppers wanting both style and substance.

4. IT Cosmetics: The Long-Haul Performer

IT Cosmetics earned CR’s “Longest-Lasting” , shedding just 4 bristles after 300 rigorous uses—equivalent to a year of regular wear. Its Bye Bye Shedding™ system combines ultra-dense synthetic bristles with a double-layer adhesive (a rubber base + waterproof glue) at the ferrule. “Even with frequent deep cleaning, the bristles stayed intact,” testers noted. Targeting users who wear makeup daily, prices range from $22–$45, positioning it as an investment piece for durability-focused consumers.

5. EcoTools: Eco-Friendly & Low-Shed

EcoTools proved sustainability and performance can coexist, shedding 3 bristles in 75 uses. Made with recycled plastic bristles, soy-based glue, and bamboo handles, it’s CR’s top “Eco-Conscious” choice. Its PlantBristle™ fibers are surprisingly resilient, and the brand’s crimp-and-glue ferrule design ensures minimal loosening. At $6–$15, it’s perfect for eco-minded shoppers on a budget who refuse to compromise on quality.

Final Takeaway

When shopping for brushes, prioritize brands with reinforced ferrules, high-quality adhesives, and treated bristles—key to minimal shedding. Whether you’re a pro (Sigma), a daily user (IT Cosmetics), or eco-focused (EcoTools), these top 5 from Consumer Reports 2025 deliver a smooth, frustration-free makeup experience.